Readers remember Lucy Maud Montgomery as a talented writer who brought one of children’s most memorable characters to life with her Anne of Green Gables series. Fans of Anne certainly hold a special place in their hearts for the author. However, many may not know the truth about her life and tragic death. After Anne by Logan Steiner imagines what life for Maud may have been like. In a time when women were expected to marry and have children, Maud didn’t quite fit the mold. And her inner battle to remain a devoted partner while following her dreams never left her unbothered. 

I’ll preface this review by warning that this opinion is based on just After Anne, and not on the Anne of Green Gables series. Because I have never read them. Readers can rest assured that Anne had no hold on me while I read Stiener’s take. That being said, those who are familiar with Anne will take comfort in experiencing the character’s development through Maud’s inner monologues. Anne becomes another voice in Maud’s head, taking a life of her own. Eventually Anne becomes more than just a fictional character, but rather an indication of Maud’s wellbeing. 

Maud lives with her grandmother and meets a handsome young minister, Ewan McDonald. She is expected to become Ewan’s wife and have his children. However, she isn’t in any hurry to make it happen. She wants to be a published author and continue writing other stories as well. And even though she does feel affection and attraction towards Ewan, he doesn’t show much interest in her professional endeavors, which understandably disappoints her. Her cousin Frede seems to be the only one in her life who not only believes in her but also encourages her. 

As most of us know and are likely grateful for, Maud did indeed publish her books and continued writing other stories. She had also released volumes of her personal journals that served as the basis for After Anne. But Steiner humanizes Maud’s experiences and imagines them as they happened. She includes context – what might have Maud been thinking when she realized that she can’t put off her decisions forever? What angst must she have felt at the loss of those most important to her? And towards the end of her life, what had she been going through to have it end so tragically? Readers get answers to these questions plus more. 

Fans of historical fiction and period dramas are sure to enjoy After Anne. Personally, the pacing was a bit slow.. Also, there are flashbacks and time jumps that can be kind of confusing if you aren’t paying attention. In any case, those who love the Anne of Green Gables books are sure to enjoy exploring a deeper level of understanding the woman behind the pen. I know I’m glad to have had the opportunity.

Logan Steiner joins us for a Cantina Conversation for The Nerd Cantina Show podcast. She talks about how her career in law prepared her for this project and the challenges of writing her first book. Keep an ear out for the interview in an upcoming episode and preorder After Anne, available May 30.